Had four estimates from well regarded/highly rated (all Master rated contractors per manufacturers) roofing companies in the area. I will note Jayhawk in particular came highly recommended by a home inspector who’s “been on a lot of roofs” and I asked for an objective opinion, regardless of price, and he felt they were the best and very consistent in terms of quality workmanship. Out of the four estimates I received I’ll note two, Jayhawk and Jim Hicks Home Improvement, did the best job of educating me on my options and most importantly were “honest” in their assessment of my needs. When I say honest, let’s just say other contractors tried to convince me I needed a “complete roofing system” that included closing off my gables, adding ridge vents, new sheathing, etc. Jayhawk (and Jim Hicks) explained to me all of that was unnecessary — my current ventilation with the gables has been working properly on my house since 1957, they both asked “why do you need to add ridge vents/soffits to fix something that isn’t broken?”... “why replace the original sturdy 1x’s in great condition with new thinner plywood sheathing?”. You get the idea. They weren’t trying to nickel and dime me; they were trying to put the best roof on my house. Needless to say Jayhawk came in at a much more reasonable price than the other guys. They gave me a detailed estimate, included different options for shingle types, and even the cost for potential incidental charges like if they found a bad sheathing board that needed replacing (which they did and consequently gave me a discount on) - no surprise charges! I received my estimate from Jayhawk on 11/2... chose them on 11/8... they had me scheduled for 11/10. The crew arrived early at 6:15am, set up, covered up my bushes, brought a trash trailer up the driveway and were hard at it before the sun was up. I did some running around in the morning and got to see the progress throughout as I came and went, I’ll just say their crew was extremely efficient! I ended up leaving for the day around 11:30am and they pretty much had the new roof on by then. They did a complete tear off of old roof > replaced broken boards > applied Diamond Deck underlayment > weather protection in necessary areas > drip edging > new Certainteed Landmark Pro shingles > cleaned up everything as if they were never even there and left an extra “just in case” bundle of shingles. Done in one day. I’m extremely happy with the how my roof looks and how I expect it will hold up over the years.

Just as a heads up to anyone - these people don't do repairs. Oh well.